My Photo

Bookish Places

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Yet Another Library Sale | Main | Teaser Tuesday: Trying to Choose »

Comments

iliana

Wow, what a story. It sounds very complex, brutal but definitely worthwhile. I admit this wouldn't be my typical read and if I had just read the book jacket I probably wouldn't think of adding to my list but reading you review will make me consider this one.

Danielle

Iliana--I think a second read would be good--now that I know what to expect I could read for the deeper meaning. It was definitely outside my normal reading comfort zone, which is something that's good to do now and again.

litlove

What a courageous reader you are! I sort of knew from the start that I wouldn't get through this one. But it sounds like a very powerful piece of literature and the kind of novel about ethical concerns that a person really ought to read.

jenclair

I just googled more info about the vivisections performed on POWs...and don't think I could get through the book. I wasn't aware that this had occurred.

Penny

Just reading about this book in this sensitive and well written review you have given here makes me uneasy, Danielle. I have read about the horrors of war, both fiction and nonfiction, and travel through those pages uncomfortably but make it through them, but, vivisections is almost more than I can handle. Then, I think, if I don't hear and read about such atrocities, do I help to perpetuate their occurrences by turning my head away?
Provocative review - and I might at least give The Sea and Poison a try.

Danielle

Litlove--It's a great book to read in a group or book club. I didn't quite realize what the subject matter was at first--just bought the book knowing it was about WWII. Thankfully it wasn't really explicit--almost clinical really, but it's amazing what your imagination can fill in!
Jenclair--I read another book a while back that referenced vivisections on POWs so I was aware--but it is extremely distasteful to think about. There were only a few scenes that were unpleasant, and nothing graphic, but otherwise a really excellent book.
Penny--I haven't read any books about WWII for a long time and it is uncomfortable to think about.I had never read about this particular occurrence--it makes you wonder how wars can keep happening--it's all really terribly sad. I'm glad I read it for just the reason you mention--educating yourself on the world and history would hopefully make us wiser. I do hope I've not put people off--it was not as bad as I was expecting--Endo seemed to treat it all very sensitively. It is one that I do recommend!

Caroline

Strange, I left a long comment yesterday thanking you for participating and adding a few things... It has gone.
Well, here goes - somewhat changed- , thanks for participating and your thoughtful review. I'm glad I read Novroz' review first and knew that it wouldn't be graphic. It's not a nice book but a very interesting, bleak look at human nature.

Stefanie

Wow, this sounds really good in spite of all the horror. Glad to hear it isn't that graphic. I have a chance then of acutally reading it!

Danielle

Caroline--Sorry about that--not sure what happened but I hate it when comments get eaten up. I checked my spam folder in the off chance it ended up there, but nothing but nasty messages that were immediately deleted by me. You did let me know but I guess it was the few references I had read about the experiments that had me a little on edge. It is not a pleasant story, but it was interesting and well done, too.
Stefanie--If it were a movie (and actually I think it was indeed made into a movie) there are a few scenes where I would cover my eyes, but most of the story is scene setting. I think you'll be safe if you ever decide to read it.

Dorothy W.

This sounds really interesting. I wonder if it would make a good pairing with the H.G. Wells novel we read with the Slaves? That was about vivisection as well, although of animals in that case. It sounds like a really interesting, if difficult, book.

Danielle

Dorothy--This is a great book to read in a group as there is lots to talk about--I hadn't thought of the Wells but they would be good to read together to contrast--lots of ethical matters in both! Both were good reads.

Anna Horner

Thanks for linking to my review. This was a very dark book and it certainly gives you much to think about. I just had problems with the structure; it really was all over the place!

I'll link to your review on War Through the Generations.

Danielle

Anna--It was very dark. I think I was so caught up in the story that the way Endo framed it sort of flew by me, but thinking back it does move around a lot. I had to flip back to see who had just talked and how the characters related. Somehow I think this is a book that would do well with a second read, though I'm not sure I'll be brave enough to do so anytime soon.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Books Read in 2020

Books Read in 2019

Books Read in 2018

Books Read in 2017

Books Read in 2016

Books Read in 2015