My Photo

Bookish Places

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Lillian and Dash | Main | Laura Lamont's Life in Pictures by Emma Straub »

Comments

Caroline


****Spoiler*****
I read this yesterday and was going to send you an e-mail.
I must honestly admit, it's not a bad story. It's well written, descriptive but is it worth a Dagger? I don't think so. It's so similar to the DuMaurier and to Ian NcEwan's The Comfort of Strangers plus you know from the first time she mentions John where this is going. I was hoping until the end that I would be wrong but no it played out like that. I think she writes really well but I would have thought the Dagger goes to something more original. Gaiman's story is another pastiche, as far as I saw.

Kathy

Sounds just creepy enough. There's already a slight element of anxiety when one is out of one's own comfort zone, especially when the language is different. I can imagine the suspense mounting...

Stefanie

Ooo, sounds creepy. Too bad you can't get the other two stories. I'm sure they aren't that good anyway ;)

Danielle

I was thinking too of Daphne Du Maurier as I was reading, and you're right about the McEwan. I liked it, thought it was well written as well--but I do know what you mean by being award material. Of course it might have been the best of the batch--I wish I could have gotten my hands on the other two. I think its hard sometimes with short stories to be really, really original and clever. I liked the Gaiman okay, but I am not a big Sherlock Holmes fan so I think that story was a bit lost on me--still thought it was good--but just not quite to my taste. I think of my favorites from the stories I read--the one that has been most memorable was the one that won a previous dagger! (Margaret Murphy's The Message).

Danielle

Setting is so important with mysteries I think. A really good setting helps set the tone of the story and create tension and suspense as you say! I've enjoyed all my mystery stories, though I think I am ready to get back to something a bit more domestic!

Danielle

That's what I'm trying to tell myself! If only a Kindle version would be available I'd ask my library to buy it so I could read them! :) Maybe I'll eventually find a nice used copy or it will be published in the US. And like you say, maybe I'm not actually missing out....? :)

Liz F

I suppose it is true that there are a limited number of storylines, particularly when it comes to mysteries but I seem to have read a few recently where I have got halfway through and realised that I knew exactly how it was going to end because it was effectively a tweaked version of another book.

iliana

Oh I love how you describe the setting for this - I want to read it! I'm on a bit of a library ban so I can read more of my books but I may have to see if my library carries this book.

Danielle

I wonder if it is especially hard with a crime novel/story. It seems like its all been done before, so I am especially impressed when an author manages to floor me--most recently Alex by Pierre Lemaitre did it.

Danielle

It's one to keep in mind for later maybe--for RIP in Oct? I love story collections like the one this story came out of and wouldn't mind owning it. And I love a story with good atmosphere--she manages to convey that paranoia well.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Books Read in 2020

Books Read in 2019

Books Read in 2018

Books Read in 2017

Books Read in 2016

Books Read in 2015