My Photo

Bookish Places

Categories

Blog powered by Typepad

« Angela Carter's Fairy Tales, Part 1 | Main | Reading Notes: Reading The Netherlands »

Comments

litlove

Oh I love the idea of Mary Steward adaptations in the style of 50s Hitchcock! That would be completely fabulous. I really enjoyed this one, too, when I read it, but I had no idea it was only her second novel! You're right it does feel a little different, but is every bit as gripping as her later works.

Stefanie

Oh this sounds like fun and I can totally see it as a movie!

Kathy

Too bad you're not in charge of turning Mary Stewart's books into movies--I like your vision! To my knowledge, only one of her books has been made into a movie, The Moon-Spinners, and it is positively unrecognizable.

Compared to today's entertainment, Mary Stewart's books are sedate, but they are full of likable characters, suspense, lovely settings, and I find them absolutely irresistable. Life itself is a little too rough and hair-raising--I prefer gentle romance, and suspense rather than terror and grit in my entertainment.

Janet

Disney made a movie of her Moon-Spinners starring Hayley Mills and I can remember another of her books being made into a movie, but I can't remember which one.
Love her books have read and reread all of them.

cath

They would definitely need a really good director, like Hitchcock. I'd hate to see them spoiled.

melwyk

I haven't read this one yet; I too keep some unread in reserve :) This one sounds perfect for a Hitchcock film for sure. Love the set up, it sounds like a film.

Judith

I totally agree that most of Mary Stewart's novels would have made, in the "right" hands, spectacular films.

I am a devotee of Wildfire at Midnight, and gosh--if there weren't so many other books to be read, I'd reread it immediately.

Judith

Danielle

She's so good--I always enjoy her books and have a nice, neat little pile of them to look forward to reading--may have to ration them out, though. I love that era of the 50s--it was (seemed anyway) so elegant. Of course it helps that I love Alfred Hitchcock, so I can totally see her stories filtered through his directing.

Danielle

It might well be my favorite of her books now... Her stories would make such great movies--I am surprised they have never been filmed!

Danielle

Oh, yes, you're right--Hayley Mills starred in it, didn't she? I think I saw it, or parts of it a very long time ago. Now I want to read the book before I watch the movie--it is one I am holding back as I am sure I will love that Greek setting. Or maybe it is better to forgo the film? I am with you on liking stories that are pretty sedate--well, mostly anyway. I guess I do read a lot of crime novels, but there is mystery and crime and then there is gorey stuff, which I try and steer clear of. I know what I'll get with a Mary Stewart book and that is just fine with me--I know it will be something good to look forward to--picking up one of her books.

Danielle

I forgot about The Moon-spinners. I will have to investigate now. I read her Arthur/Merlin books a long time ago and have only in the last few years started reading her romantic suspense and find I love those books! I am rationing them out now, though I will happily reread her work!

Danielle

Yes, I agree! I think Hollywood would spoil them completely. There is something restrained about Hitchcock--true suspense, which I think would work well. Of course sometimes it's best to just stick with the books!

Danielle

I really enjoyed this--loved the setting. It seemed shorter than the other books by her I've read, but maybe because it was an early book. Nothing wrong with with that--she did everything she needed to. Wouldn't those sorts of films work well with these stories?! And I have a small pile in reserve, too, which I am rationing out!

Danielle

Hi Judith--I could see them as old B&W movies, too. But maybe better to leave them alone considering what most movies are like these days. I loved Wildfire at Midnight--such a great protagonist. And I really wasn't sure who the killer was until almost the very end. I would love to go to the Isle of Skye (even if fishing and climbing are not my things!).

Joan Kyler

I bought four Mary Stewart paperback novels (The Ivy Tree, The Moon-Spinners, Nine Coaches Waiting, and Airs Above the Ground) for $1.00 each when I was in Boston. They look like they've never been read. It's been years since I read any Mary Stewart and I'm looking forward to a little binge reading one of these hot summer days.

I, too, wish that Hollywood would make movies like the older ones, but using the restrained hand of a master like Hitchcock. They were so stylish and nuanced and atmospheric.

Margaret Powling

I must correct you on one detail, Danielle: the Queen's Coronation was in 1953, not 1956. She ascended the throne on 6th February 1952 and was crowned on 2nd June 1953 - it took over a year to prepare for this event.
I am sure that I once started Wildfire at Midnight but didn't finish it. This has been the case with several Mary Stewart books although I read Airs Above the Ground many, many years ago and enjoyed that but, even at the time, thought that the story was a most unlikely one and so I wasn't able to suspend belief entirely!

Danielle

Sorry about that-yes, you're absolutely right. The error was on my part. I think I had 1956 in mind as that is the year the book was published but on checking back in the text it refers to that summer in 1953! I have corrected my post, so thanks for the clarification. I've enjoyed all the books I have read by her, but I know not every book is going to appeal to every reader. Sometimes I don't mind stretching belief just a little--and in the case of Mary Stewart, I guess I don't mind it at all. :) Thankfully there are so many reading options out there there is always another author around the corner to satisfy our desires!

betty hale

I also love Mary Stewart's books and I loved the film version of The Moon Spinners. I had a mad crush on the male lead, Peter McEnery, and wanted to be Haley Mills, so the movie worked for me. Of course I have a copy of the book and about a year or so ago, got a copy of the movie and I watch it every now and then. I visited Greece when I was in my 20s, so that when I watch the movie, it brings back fond memories of that trip.

Coincidentally, I was just thinking that I needed to pick up a book that would take me to someplace like Greece or the South of France, and had thought that I would look for a Mary Stewart book to read(I have a number of her books). So thank you for this very timely post.

Danielle

What great finds! I admit when I heard she passed away I ordered a few more books to have on hand knowing I was going to want to read more of her work sooner than later. I only read her Merlin books years ago--I think I didn't even realize she had written romantic suspense, but I have quite enjoyed each and every story I've picked up so far. Alfred Hitchcock is pretty unique, isn't he? I know there are loads of suspenseful movies, but there is really something special about the movies he directed

Danielle

I have not read the book, seen the movie or been to Greece! I hope to have all three ahead of me to look forward to! :) I have always liked Haley Mills (my favorite--the Paren Trap). I'll have to read the book and then watch the movie--but maybe not too close together and let each stand on its own. Happy always to point a reader in the direction of a good book. I think the next Mary Stewart I might pick up will be Madame Will You Talk, which is set in France I think? I like to keep a few of her books in reserve and am only slowly reading my way through them!

Caroline

Thinking of what he did with du Maurier's Rebecca, I could imagine Hitchcock would do a great job with this story.
It sounds very good, certainly one I'd love to read too.
Great review.

Danielle

Thanks Caroline. Rebecca is such a great movie--I loved the book. It is one of my all-time favorites. And the movie is good too. I have it in mind now as 'the' Rebecca movie and have not been able to watch the remake or read any sequel to the book--I think on both counts it would spoil the original for me!

The comments to this entry are closed.

Books Read in 2020

Books Read in 2019

Books Read in 2018

Books Read in 2017

Books Read in 2016

Books Read in 2015